Town hall meeting on impact of Brexit attracts diverse audience


Peter Andrews chaired the ground-breaking event which encouraged residents with strongly divergent views on Brexit to listen and engage with each other. Photo © Clive Dellard.

Brexit and its implications for the broader BANES community was the theme of a debate on 12th April organised by Bath for Europe and Leave 2Remain. The two non-party political groups are staunchly pro-Remain but the pioneering event was conceived to bring both Leavers and Remainers together to talk about issues that matter to them. “The referendum vote was one of the most divisive issues, splitting communities and families but eventually we’ll have to live and work together in the same place,” said Chairman Peter Andrews in his opening statement. He emphasised the importance of being tolerant of others’ views which set the tone for the debate.

Seven members of the local community, forming a ‘Question Time’ style panel that represented sectors including business, farming, the law and non-UK/EU residents, began with a brief introduction about what Brexit would mean to them personally. Musician and producer Tim Hegarty, one of the major Leave campaigners in the South West, considered the Brexit vote reflected the elite’s lack of concern for working class British people and urged Remainers to respect the referendum result. Claire Thomas, Chair of Bath for Europe, brought in her professional expertise in construction, an industry just getting back on its feet after the recession, that was now seeing redundancies and cancelled contracts. The view that business would suffer once Brexit kicked in was echoed by other members of the panel with experience in retail who saw their livelihoods threatened with sales plummeting and costs up, reinforced by news of major chains such as New Look and Next facing major losses.

The panel of local residents from a variety of backgrounds shared their views on what Brexit would mean to the Bath and Northeast Somerset area. Photo © Clive Dellard.

The economy’s a tricky subject and one Leaver in the audience disagreed it was suffering, citing a sudden peak in the FTSE. This was challenged as being a natural consequence of the low pound. Former UKIP candidate Ernie Blaber asked if mass migration had affected house prices which opened the debate into a discussion as to whether successive governments had planned properly by building the right infrastructure to cope with an influx. The idea there had been uncontrolled immigration from the EU was also challenged as a myth and it was pointed out the Brexodus of foreign doctors, nurses and care workers would place an additional burden on the NHS. Panellist David Banwell, a local farmer, gave the example of Shepton Mallet community hospital having to close an inpatient unit temporarily because of a shortage of nurses.

“I fell in love with Britain,” said panellist Veronique Martin, when she came over from France in 1984 as part of the first wave of Erasmus students. She said now, like many EU nationals, she did not now feel so welcome, but added, “We are all people with similar dreams and fears and wish the best for Britain.” With so many strong views, it was unlikely there would be consensus but Remainers and Leavers did listen to the views of others and enjoyed the social atmosphere of Midsomer Norton Town Hall’s Assembly Room in sharing a drink afterwards.

Jane Riekemann